| Warren P. Spencer+ | 1919 | 1962 |
| Anne A. Davis+ | 1915 | 1963 |
| John McSweeney+ | 1912 | 1965 |
| George A. Mosel+ | 1916 | 1966 |
| Wilson M. Compton+ | 1940 | 1967 |
| Waldo H. Dunn+ | 1906 | 1967 |
| Albert I. Good+ | 1906 | 1968 |
| Gideon D. Hatfield+ | 1909 | 1970 |
| Donald A. Lowrie+ | 1940 | 1971 |
| Charles E. Mc Dermott+ | 1924 | 1961 |
| Lewis F. Mayer+ | 1920 | 1961 |
| Charles A. Dilley+ | 1930 | 1961 |
| Paul C. Hawk+ | 1925 | 1962 |
| William M. Alrich+ | 1939 | 1962 |
| Francis P. Twinem+ | 1917 | 1963 |
| John C. Johnston+ | 1938 | 1963 |
| Ruth (Wylie) Eschbach+ | 1939 | 1964 |
| George L. Dixon+ | 1922 | 1964 |
| Lister O. Weiss+ | 1920 | 1964 |
| Edna (Fetzer) Weiss+ | 1927 | 1964 |
| Robert L. Myers+ | 1939 | 1965 |
| William M. McCulloch+ | 1923 | 1965 |
| Robert G. Bone+ | 1928 | 1966 |
| Alma E. Gault+ | 1916 | 1966 |
| Edwin M. Wright+ | 1918 | 1967 |
| Helen (Harrington) Compton+ | 1912 | 1967 |
| John R. Milligan | 1949 | 1968 |
| John D. McKee+ | 1917 | 1968 |
| Eva (Castner) Swan+ | 1918 | 1969 |
| Howard F. Lowry+ | 1923 | 1969 |
| David A. Redding+ | 1946 | 1969 |
| Alfred W. Swan+ | 1917 | 1969 |
| Carl M. Toensmeier+ | 1931 | 1969 |
| Esther (Lane) Toensmeier+ | 1930 | 1969 |
| David A. Cort+ | 1932 | 1970 |
| J. C. Wynn+ | 1941 | 1970 |
| Robert G. Wilder+ | 1942 | 1971 |
| Clara (Gharber) Lewis+ | 1933 | 1971 |
| G. Ernest Wright+ | 1931 | 1972 |
| William H. Havener+ | 1944 | 1972 |
| Jeanne Christy+ | 1926 | 1972 |
| John F. Boyd+ | 1942 | 1973 |
| William R. Schultz+ | 1933 | 1973 |
| Jane (Cotton) Boyd+ | 1942 | 1973 |
| James M. Dawson+ | 1939 | 1973 |
| Charles B. Moke+ | 1931 | 1974 |
| Dwight C. Hanna+ | 1944 | 1974 |
| Alfreda (Gabriel) Campbell+ | 1941 | 1974 |
| Ernest Y. Campbell+ | 1940 | 1974 |
| Sanford P. Lehman+ | 1928 | 1975 |
| Juliet (Stroh) Blanchard+ | 1924 | 1975 |
| Lucy L. Notestein+ | 1911 | 1976 |
| Shannon McCune+ | 1935 | 1976 |
| Scott Craig | 1956 | 1976 |
| James V. Neel+ | 1935 | 1977 |
| Donald W. Raley+ | 1927 | 1977 |
| James A. Miller+ | 1928 | 1977 |
| Carolyn (Gustafson) Dix+ | 1932 | 1977 |
| Jerrold K. Footlick | 1956 | 1978 |
| Harriet (Painter) Hopkins+ | 1932 | 1978 |
| Viola (Startzman) Robertson+ | 1935 | 1978 |
| W. Dean Hopkins+ | 1930 | 1978 |
| Sherman A. Wengerd+ | 1936 | 1979 |
| John J. Compton+ | 1949 | 1979 |
| John Exter+ | 1932 | 1979 |
| Marion (Fitch) Exter+ | 1933 | 1979 |
| Donald B. Register | 1959 | 1980 |
| Helen (Murray) Free+ | 1945 | 1980 |
| John E. Wallace+ | 1912 | 1980 |
| William F. Kieffer+ | 1936 | 1981 |
| Erma (Wooding) Foley+ | 1938 | 1981 |
| Frank W. Notestein+ | 1923 | 1981 |
| Lowell B. Bourns+ | 1927 | 1982 |
| William McAfee+ | 1932 | 1982 |
| Mary (Courtney) Bourns+ | 1927 | 1982 |
| James C. Mikkelsen+ | 1942 | 1982 |
| Stanley C. Gault+ | 1948 | 1983 |
| H. Alberta Colclaser+ | 1933 | 1983 |
| Robert R. Cadmus+ | 1936 | 1983 |
| Ernest M. Hole+ | 1918 | 1984 |
| Russell H. Seibert+ | 1930 | 1984 |
| Catherine (Compton) Chase+ | 1944 | 1984 |
| Edward B. Westlake+ | 1925 | 1985 |
| John W. Pocock+ | 1938 | 1985 |
| Catherine B. Hess+ | 1937 | 1985 |
| James R. Baroffio | 1954 | 1986 |
| Betty (Dickens) Neuhart+ | 1945 | 1986 |
| Stanley R. Welty+ | 1924 | 1987 |
| Jon R. Waltz+ | 1951 | 1987 |
| Ralph A. Young+ | 1929 | 1987 |
| Dorothy McCuskey+ | 1929 | 1987 |
| George W. Thorn+ | 1927 | 1988 |
| Henry C. Miller+ | 1944 | 1988 |
| Stephen R. Donaldson | 1968 | 1989 |
| Lois (Barr) Cook+ | 1945 | 1989 |
| Erie Mills | 1975 | 1989 |
| Robert S. Laubach+ | 1941 | 1989 |
| Eric H. Boehm+ | 1940 | 1990 |
| Marguerite (Lane) Bowden+ | 1940 | 1990 |
| Christine Camp+ | 1951 | 1990 |
| Catherine A. Tisinger | 1958 | 1991 |
| James N. Wise+ | 1941 | 1991 |
| G. T. Smith | 1956 | 1991 |
| James R. Blackwood+ | 1941 | 1992 |
| Robert H. Atwell | 1953 | 1992 |
| Ralph W. Schreiber+ | 1964 | 1992 |
| Alice (McGrew) Hawk+ | 1926 | 1992 |
| David D. Dowd+ | 1951 | 1993 |
| John P. Papp+ | 1960 | 1993 |
| William R. McGraw+ | 1952 | 1993 |
| Priscilla (Miller) Hart | 1951 | 1994 |
| Merton M. Sealts+ | 1937 | 1994 |
| Timothy P. Smucker | 1967 | 1995 |
| Ruth (Frost) Parker+ | 1945 | 1995 |
| Susan Q. Stranahan | 1968 | 1996 |
| Earl W. Wendell | 1950 | 1996 |
| Lois (Lyon) Neumann | 1949 | 1996 |
| Charles E. Rath | 1940 | 1997 |
| Norvin J. Hein+ | 1937 | 1997 |
| Dorothy (Robins) Mowry | 1942 | 1997 |
| William J. Yoder | 1963 | 1998 |
| Donald L. Kohn | 1964 | 1998 |
| Lee (Eberhardt) Limbird | 1970 | 1998 |
| John C. Buechner+ | 1956 | 1999 |
| Paul L. Kendall | 1964 | 1999 |
| Solomon Oliver | 1969 | 2000 |
| Molly (Fritz) Miller | 1969 | 2000 |
| David L. Beveridge | 1959 | 2001 |
| Edith (Bender) Seaton+ | 1947 | 2001 |
| Ronald S. Seaton+ | 1947 | 2001 |
| James F. Leckman | 1969 | 2001 |
| Edward McCreight | 1966 | 2002 |
| Maurice E. Hole | 1956 | 2002 |
| Lois (Black) Bing+ | 1931 | 2002 |
| Lynne (Cherry) McCreight | 1966 | 2002 |
| Tom M. Johnson | 1956 | 2003 |
| Lawson W. Stoneburner+ | 1937 | 2003 |
| Eugene C. Bay | 1959 | 2003 |
| W. Lee Culp+ | 1941 | 2004 |
| John E. Smeltz+ | 1944 | 2004 |
| Scott L. Behoteguy+ | 1939 | 2004 |
| Edward C. Arn+ | 1931 | 2005 |
| Miriam R. Pride | 1970 | 2005 |
| Joan P. Carter | 1965 | 2005 |
| Richard S. Foster | 1971 | 2006 |
| Denise (Ducharme) Reilly | 1975 | 2006 |
| Niall W. Slater | 1976 | 2006 |
| James A. Fletcher | 1967 | 2007 |
| Joseph J. Catino | 1974 | 2007 |
| Linda (Marsch) Saif | 1969 | 2007 |
| Alpha V. Alexander | 1976 | 2008 |
| Katharine (Doob) Sakenfeld | 1961 | 2008 |
| Gary W. Reichard | 1965 | 2008 |
| Cynthia S. Tice+ | 1958 | 2009 |
| Wayne A. Cornelius | 1967 | 2009 |
| Jay R. Gates | 1968 | 2009 |
| Alvin J. Van Wie+ | 1952 | 2010 |
| Jane (Morley) Kotchen | 1960 | 2010 |
| Dale M. Swift | 1980 | 2010 |
| Angene (Hopkins) Wilson | 1961 | 2011 |
| Clarence R. Williams | 1963 | 2011 |
| David A. Dunlop | 1973 | 2011 |
| Jack A. Wilson | 1961 | 2011 |
| Irwin L. Reese | 1975 | 2012 |
| Thomas K. Welty | 1965 | 2012 |
| Ronald C. Hughes | 1970 | 2012 |
| James T. Clarke | 1959 | 2013 |
| Diane K. Jorkasky | 1973 | 2013 |
| Kenneth C. Fischer | 1966 | 2013 |
| Carl W. Cotman | 1962 | 2014 |
| Z. Mike Chirenje | 1977 | 2014 |
| James A. McClung | 1959 | 2014 |
| David R. Hopkins | 1970 | 2015 |
| Barbara (Frajola) Atkinson | 1964 | 2015 |
| Elizabeth A. Eaton | 1977 | 2016 |
| Lucius F. Ellsworth | 1963 | 2016 |
| George H. Davis | 1964 | 2016 |
| T. William Evans | 1960 | 2017 |
| Judith (Mack) Patterson | 1963 | 2017 |
| Laurie S. Priest | 1977 | 2017 |
| David W. Douglas | 1971 | 2018 |
| Richard A. Kerr | 1968 | 2018 |
| Macharia Kamau | 1982 | 2019 |
| Patricia J. Vittum | 1974 | 2019 |
| Brenda N. Major | 1972 | 2020 |
| Larry A. Jones | 1975 | 2020 |
| Walt P. Hopkins | 1966 | 2021 |
| Katharine (Rhodes) Henderson | 1978 | 2021 |
